An independent institute of public policy research · Lucknow, India

The Research Library · Social Equality and Stability · Commentary

Ink, Paper and Pedigree: A History of India’s Electoral Roll

From the 28 lakh women missing in 1951-52 to the Special Intensive Revision, the roll’s history shows what a sound revision must do before it deletes a name.

Ink, Paper and Pedigree: A History of India’s Electoral Roll

India’s electoral roll has never been a finished document. It began as an act of faith, was corrected within months of its first use, and has been cleaned, widened and re-cleaned in cycles ever since. The question raised by the current Special Intensive Revision (SIR) is not whether the roll should be revised, because it always has been. It is how much of the old settlement, in which the state does the work of finding the voter and a name is removed only on evidence, should survive a faster and more demanding revision.

Adult suffrage, and India’s electoral roll with holes

The Constitution settled who may vote before anyone had compiled the list. Article 326 gives every citizen who is of age, and not otherwise disqualified, the entitlement to be registered as a voter; the original text set the age at twenty-one, and the text now reads eighteen. The roll that followed was necessarily imperfect. According to a Deccan Herald account of the 1951-52 election, about 28 lakh women were struck off because they had been listed only as somebody’s wife or mother, and many were reluctant to give their own names to strangers. Chief Election Commissioner Sukumar Sen’s Commission required a proper name for every voter, extended deadlines in Bihar and Rajasthan, and had officials persuade women to register. By the 1957 elections, the same account says, 92,141,597 women were on the roll, which Sen estimated at about 94 per cent of adult women.

The lesson is that the first great revision of the roll was an expansion, driven by the state going to the voter. The burden of finding the citizen fell on the administration.

A statute with room for different kinds of revision

The Representation of the People Act, 1950 gives the Commission the legal tools. As the Supreme Court Observer explains, Section 21(3) allows a “special revision”, and Rule 25 of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 permits intensive or summary revisions, though neither term is defined in statute. In practice, summary revisions were annual and intensive revisions came roughly every five years before elections. LiveLaw’s analysis adds that “special intensive revision” appears in neither the Act nor the Rules.

ThePrint’s survey of earlier exercises lists eight previous intensive revisions, in 1952-56, 1958-61, 1965-66, 1983-84, 1987-88, 1993, 1995 and 2002-2004, and finds that each added more voters than it removed. After the comprehensive revision of 1993, the Supreme Court Observer notes, digitisation and Electors’ Photo Identity Cards reduced the need for such exercises, and only summary revisions were run until the revision of 2003. Alongside the expansion, a rule of fairness grew up. In Lal Babu Hussein v. Electoral Registration Officer (1995), as the Observer describes it, the Court treated an existing roll as a basis for presuming that a person remained enrolled, required positive proof for deletions, and insisted on a fair hearing.

What changed in 2025

The Observer, in a March 2026 analysis, sets out three differences. The Commission announced the Bihar revision in June 2025, about five months before the state election. Voters who could not trace themselves to the 2003 roll had to produce one of eleven prescribed documents, which the author calls a “reverse burden of proof.” And the exercise was compressed; LiveLaw’s July 2025 analysis says the Bihar SIR ran in about 30 days, where the 2003 revision had taken roughly a year.

The numbers that followed explain why the argument is heated. ThePrint’s October 2026 count, which it stresses is based on draft lists, found 13.39 crore of 95.40 crore voters reviewed placed in removal categories, with 6.30 crore marked as permanently shifted and 2.80 crore as deceased. It also found this was the only revision in its comparison in which the rolls shrank. Former Chief Election Commissioner O.P. Rawat told the paper that the main reason was the shift of the burden of proof onto voters, who in many cases were not helped to map themselves; former CEC T.S. Krishnamurthy said that he was not surprised by large omissions and that alleging bad faith requires “foolproof evidence”.

The strongest case against the sceptics

The strongest defence of SIR is that the roll had grown stale. Urbanisation, migration, unreported deaths and duplicates are real, and a roll that carries them damages every election by making turnout look low and results open to suspicion. A former state chief electoral officer told ThePrint that rolls had become “very bloated” after the 2002-03 exercise. Past revisions grew the roll partly because the earlier rolls were thin; today the problem is the opposite.

The Supreme Court has also agreed on the law. In Association for Democratic Reforms v. Election Commission of India, decided on 27 May 2026 and reported as 2026 INSC 564, the Court upheld the Bihar SIR as traceable to Section 21(3) read with Article 324 and as proportionate, according to Legal Republic’s summary. The same summary records limits that matter: the Commission may make only a prima facie inquiry into citizenship for enrolment, must refer doubtful cases to the competent authority under the Citizenship Act, 1955 for decision after notice and hearing, and must restore names of those later found to be citizens.

Where the line should be

The history suggests a test, not a verdict. A revision is sound when it does three things: it starts from the old roll rather than ignoring it, it puts the work of tracing the voter on the administration before it puts it on the citizen, and it deletes only after notice and a hearing. The Commission’s reply to critics should therefore be about practice, not power. It has the power. The remaining question is how much help the Booth Level Officer gives a woman who has moved after marriage, or a daily-wage worker who has gone to another state, before the name is dropped.

India’s first Chief Election Commissioner solved the problem of missing names by going to the voter. His successors have a legal win. They should now show, in the final rolls and in the reconciliation that follows, that the old tradition of finding the citizen survives the new method of testing the roll.

Frequently asked questions

What happened to women voters in the first general election?
According to a Deccan Herald account, about 28 lakh women were struck off the 1951-52 roll because they had been listed only as somebody’s wife or mother. The Commission required a proper name for every voter, and by 1957 the account says 92,141,597 women were on the roll.

Is ‘special intensive revision’ defined in law?
No. Section 21(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 allows a special revision and Rule 25 of the 1960 Rules permits intensive or summary revisions, but neither term is defined. LiveLaw notes that ‘special intensive revision’ appears in neither the Act nor the Rules.

What did the Supreme Court decide on the Bihar SIR?
In its decision of 27 May 2026, reported as 2026 INSC 564, the Court upheld the Bihar SIR as traceable to Section 21(3) read with Article 324 and as proportionate. It allowed only a prima facie inquiry into citizenship and required referral of doubtful cases to the competent authority.

What test does the article offer for a sound revision?
A revision is sound when it starts from the old roll, puts the work of tracing the voter on the administration before the citizen, and deletes only after notice and a hearing.

Further reading from AFPR: Counting the Counters: SIR Across the States, Phase by Phase · Verdict on the Voter List: What the Court Really Said

Notes and References

1. Constitution of India, Article 326 (original text: twenty-one years; current text: eighteen years), https://www.constitutionofindia.net/articles/article-326-elections-to-the-house-of-the-people-and-to-the-legislative-assemblies-of-states-to-be-on-the-basis-of-adult-suffrage/

2. Deccan Herald, “No vote for A’s mother or B’s wife in 1951 polls” (date not shown on the page; sourced for the 1951-52 omission of women and the 1957 figure), https://www.deccanherald.com/national/no-vote-for-as-mother-or-bs-wife-in-1951-polls-723152.html

3. Debjani M, Supreme Court Observer, “Beyond ‘Special’: How the 2025 Bihar SIR marks a break from the past”, 6 March 2026, https://www.scobserver.in/journal/beyond-special-how-the-2025-bihar-sir-marks-a-break-from-the-past/

4. Kritika Arora and Saksham Vaishya, LiveLaw, “Special Intensive Revision In Bihar: Statutory Authority, Constitutional Limits, And Policy Concerns”, 14 July 2025, https://www.livelaw.in/articles/bihar-elections-special-intensive-revision-voters-list-and-proof-of-citizenship-critical-analysis-297387

5. ThePrint, “All of the eight past SIRs upped the electorate. Why this is the only time voter numbers shrank”, 15 October 2026, https://theprint.in/india/governance/all-of-the-eight-past-sirs-upped-the-electorate-why-this-is-the-only-time-voter-numbers-shrank/3071676/

6. Legal Republic, “Supreme Court Upholds Bihar Electoral Roll Revision, Sets Limits on Citizenship Inquiry”, 29 May 2026 (Association for Democratic Reforms v. Election Commission of India, W.P.(C) No. 640 of 2025, decided 27 May 2026, reported as 2026 INSC 564), https://www.legalrepublic.in/supreme-court/adr-vs-eci-bihar-sir-electoral-rolls-2026/

Further reading

Pay by UPI

UPI QR code for Adhyayan Foundation, payable with any UPI appSave QR to your phone
  1. Scan with Google Pay, PhonePe, Paytm, BHIM or your bank's UPI app. On a phone, save the code and use Scan from gallery, or pay to the UPI ID below.
  2. Pay to Adhyayan Foundation and add in the note.
  3. Confirm here with the UPI reference (UTR) shown in your app after payment.

UPI ID

Payments are received by Razorpay on behalf of the Adhyayan Foundation for Policy and Research. Questions: afpr.office@gmail.com