An independent institute of public policy research · Lucknow, India

The Research Library · Good Governance and Economic Studies · Commentary

Three Lists, One Citizen: Panchayat, Municipality and Parliament

Panchayat, municipal and parliamentary rolls are meant to describe the same voter. After SIR, the gaps between them show why a common base roll is overdue.

Three Lists, One Citizen: Panchayat, Municipality and Parliament

An Indian citizen who lives in a village in Rajasthan can be a voter three times over: on the parliamentary and assembly roll kept by the Election Commission of India, on a panchayat electoral roll kept by the State Election Commission, and, if she or her family also holds a town address, on a municipal roll as well. The three lists are meant to describe one person. This year’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has shown how often they do not.

Two commissions, one constitutional text for the panchayat electoral roll

The constitutional design is clear enough. Article 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of Parliament and state legislature elections in the Election Commission. The Seventy-third and Seventy-fourth Amendments gave the same job for local bodies to State Election Commissions: Article 243K, in its own words, vests superintendence, direction and control of panchayat elections in “a State Election Commission”, and Article 243ZA does the same for municipalities. State legislatures fill in the detail by law.

What the Constitution does not do is say that the State Election Commission must draw up its roll from scratch. That choice is left to each state’s law, and states have chosen differently. Inderjit Khanna, writing in India Seminar around 2008, recorded that some state laws let the commission use the Election Commission of India roll while others require a fresh roll, and that qualifying dates for new voters differ. A 2022 explainer by Drishti IAS lists Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Odisha, Assam, Madhya Pradesh, Kerala, Arunachal Pradesh, Nagaland and Jammu and Kashmir among the states and territories that do not use the Election Commission’s roll for local polls, while others let their commissions borrow or base the local roll on it.

Why it matters now

A roll is only as honest as its last cleaning. The SIR is the largest cleaning in decades. A local-body roll that was copied from an older version of the assembly roll will carry everything the SIR set out to remove: the dead, the shifted, the duplicate.

Two recent episodes show this. In Andhra Pradesh, the Supreme Court, by a bench of the Chief Justice, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana, ruled on 9 October 2026, as reported by LawBeat, that if the SIR-revised rolls are published before the State Election Commission issues its election notification, they will be the final rolls for panchayat and urban local body polls; if not, elections go ahead on the existing rolls under Sections 11 and 12 of the Andhra Pradesh Panchayat Raj Act, 1994. The Court noted that Section 11 ties gram panchayat rolls to assembly constituency rolls. Here the law deliberately links the three lists, and the timing of one revision decides which list the village votes on.

In Rajasthan the link is looser, and the consequences are sharper. According to a report by the National Herald published on 8 October 2026, the State Election Commission built its panchayat roll on assembly rolls with a 1 January 2025 qualifying date, before the Election Commission’s final SIR roll came out on 21 February. The same report puts the net fall in the state’s electorate through the SIR at about 31 lakh and says that more than 26 lakh voters deleted by the SIR still appear on the State Election Commission’s 2026 rolls, while more than 15 lakh names on the final roll are missing from local rolls, over half of them aged 18 to 25. The report cites a study by the People’s Union for Civil Liberties and its own comparisons, is the only source for these figures, and says they vary between comparisons, so these numbers should be treated as indicative until the two commissions publish a reconciliation. Whatever the exact totals, the direction of the problem is clear: a villager who was deleted from one list may be on the other, and a first-time voter admitted to one may be missing from the other.

The strongest objection

The strongest argument against a single roll is federal and constitutional, and it deserves a proper answer. State Election Commissions were created to be independent of both the Union and the state executive. If the Election Commission of India’s roll becomes mandatory for local polls, critics say, the local commission becomes a mere organiser of polling days, and a body on which small panchayats depend loses its authority. Drishti IAS notes that a constitutional amendment to Articles 243K and 243ZA would be needed to make a single roll mandatory nationwide, and that the Centre told the Rajya Sabha it was not planning to amend the Representation of the People Act, 1951, to enable it.

This is a fair point, but it proves less than it seems. Independence in running an election does not require independence in rediscovering who lives in each house. The Law Commission’s 255th Report in 2015, as described by Drishti IAS, recommended a single roll. Earlier, the Chief Election Commissioner wrote to the Prime Minister in 1999 and 2004 proposing a common roll, and, as Khanna’s account has it, the Venkatachaliah Commission (2002) and the Second Administrative Reforms Commission backed the idea. A common database does not abolish a commissioner’s discretion over delimitation of wards, reservation, polling arrangements, nomination or counting. It removes a duplicate clerk’s task.

What a reform worth the name would look like

First, make the Election Commission’s roll the common base wherever the state law permits, as Andhra Pradesh’s Section 11 already does for gram panchayats, and let State Election Commissions add only the ward and panchayat tags that local polls need. Khanna reports that Election Commission and State Election Commission conferences agreed in principle in 2005 that the Commission’s database should record ward and panchayat numbers; it is time to finish the job. Second, require the two commissions to publish a short reconciliation note whenever a national revision such as the SIR closes, listing how many names on each list differ and why. Third, give every voter a single place to check all three entries, so the citizen does not have to hunt through three portals.

None of this needs a new constitutional principle. It needs two constitutional bodies to treat the same citizen as one person. Democracy at the lowest level is where most Indians first meet the ballot. A village should not have to ask whether the roll it votes on is the same roll the nation voted on.

Frequently asked questions

Who prepares the panchayat and municipal rolls?
Under Articles 243K and 243ZA, State Election Commissions have superintendence, direction and control of panchayat and municipal elections. Each state’s law decides whether the roll is drawn up afresh or based on the Election Commission of India’s roll.

What did the Supreme Court say about Andhra Pradesh local body polls?
On 9 October 2026 the Court ruled that if SIR-revised rolls are published before the State Election Commission issues its election notification, they will be the final rolls for panchayat and urban local body polls. Otherwise elections go ahead on the existing rolls.

How serious is the mismatch in Rajasthan?
A National Herald report puts the net fall in the electorate through SIR at about 31 lakh. It says more than 26 lakh deleted voters still appear on the State Election Commission’s rolls, though the article treats these figures as indicative.

What reforms does the article propose?
It proposes making the Election Commission’s roll the common base wherever state law permits and requiring a reconciliation note when a national revision closes. It also proposes a single place for every voter to check all three entries.

Further reading from AFPR: Counting the Counters: SIR Across the States, Phase by Phase · The Referee’s Whistle: Article 324 and the Limits of the Election Commission

Notes and References

1. Constitution of India, Articles 243K and 243ZA (as inserted by the Constitution (Seventy-third and Seventy-fourth Amendment) Acts), text as reproduced on Constitution of India (constitutionofindia.net), “Article 243K: Elections to the Panchayats”, https://www.constitutionofindia.net/articles/article-243k-elections-to-the-panchayats/ ; Article 324 as described in Khanna (item 2).

2. Inderjit Khanna, “Towards a common electoral roll”, India Seminar, issue 586 (c. 2008), https://www.india-seminar.com/2008/586/586_inderjit_khanna.htm

3. Drishti IAS, “Common Electoral Roll and Simultaneous Elections”, 5 February 2022, https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-news-analysis/common-electoral-roll-and-simultaneous-elections

4. LawBeat, “Andhra Pradesh Local Body Polls: SC Clarifies Which Electoral Rolls Will Apply After SIR”, reported 17 October 2026 (Yuvajana Shramika Rythu Congress Party v. State Election Commission, Andhra Pradesh, order of 9 October 2026; no report citation available), https://lawbeat.in/supreme-court-judgments/andhra-pradesh-local-body-polls-sc-clarifies-which-electoral-rolls-will-apply-after-sir-1642795

5. Prakash Bhandari, National Herald, “Ahead of panchayat polls, why do ECI and Rajasthan SEC have different lists?”, 8 October 2026, https://www.nationalheraldindia.com/politics/rajasthan-voter-list-discrepancy-eci-sec-sir-panchayat-polls

Further reading

Pay by UPI

UPI QR code for Adhyayan Foundation, payable with any UPI appSave QR to your phone
  1. Scan with Google Pay, PhonePe, Paytm, BHIM or your bank's UPI app. On a phone, save the code and use Scan from gallery, or pay to the UPI ID below.
  2. Pay to Adhyayan Foundation and add in the note.
  3. Confirm here with the UPI reference (UTR) shown in your app after payment.

UPI ID

Payments are received by Razorpay on behalf of the Adhyayan Foundation for Policy and Research. Questions: afpr.office@gmail.com