An independent institute of public policy research · Lucknow, India

The Research Library · Good Governance and Economic Studies · Commentary

Federal Money, State Choices: How Finance Commission Transfers Shape Policy

Maharashtra’s share of the divisible pool has edged up. Whether the money reaches Marathwada and Vidarbha depends on the conditions attached and on the state’s own choices.

Federal Money, State Choices: How Finance Commission Transfers Shape Policy

The state’s money, the state’s choice

When India’s largest state economy needs to build a hospital in Marathwada or improve water services in Vidarbha, the question is not merely whether money exists. It is who controls those resources and on what terms. Maharashtra contributes substantially to India’s economic output, yet the prosperity of Mumbai and Pune coexists with stark regional inequalities. Its ability to address them depends not only on its own revenues but also on the Union’s Finance Commission transfers and the conditions governing their use.

The Sixteenth Finance Commission’s recommendations for 2026–31 bring this tension into sharper focus. Tax devolution generally allows states to determine their spending priorities, while grants may prescribe particular purposes or require administrative compliance. Maharashtra therefore presents a fundamental dilemma. Can a formula built around statewide averages adequately recognise uneven development, and can financial accountability be secured without unduly restricting state and local policy choices?

Finance Commission transfers: who gets what, and who decides?

Article 280 of the Constitution establishes the Finance Commission to recommend the distribution of shareable Union taxes and principles governing grants-in-aid. Article 270 provides the framework for tax devolution. Unlike grants earmarked for particular purposes, devolved tax revenues generally enter the state’s budget for allocation according to its own priorities.

The Sixteenth Commission recommended retaining the states’ collective share at 41% of the divisible pool, which excludes cesses and surcharges. Within that collective allocation, Maharashtra’s share increased from 6.317% under the Fifteenth Commission to 6.441%. It is not 6.441% of all Union revenue. The change gives Maharashtra a slightly larger fraction of the states’ share but its eventual rupee receipts also depend on the size of the divisible pool.

The distinction between an entitlement and its use becomes sharper with grants. Money may be recommended for Maharashtra yet remain subject to eligibility tests, spending restrictions and release procedures. Fiscal autonomy therefore depends on more than the headline size of a transfer.

The per-capita trap: what Maharashtra’s average conceals

The Sixteenth Commission revised the criteria for dividing the states’ collective share. It reduced the weight of per-capita GSDP distance from 45% to 42.5% and introduced a 10% criterion for contribution to national GDP. That contribution is measured using the square root of a state’s GSDP, rather than awarding resources directly in proportion to its aggregate output. Income distance remains the greatest single weight, reflecting the legitimate objective of helping states with weaker fiscal capacity.

Maharashtra had urged the Commission to reduce the income-distance weight further, to 37.5%, and to recognise GDP contribution. The revised formula thus combines redistribution with recognition of economic contribution but neither criterion directly measures disparities among districts within one state. An economically powerful state can nevertheless contain places with markedly different resources and development needs. A formula based on statewide income cannot directly identify those internal disparities.

Maharashtra’s Economic Survey illustrates the divide. In 2024–25, the state’s per-capita net domestic product was estimated at ₹3,17,801, compared with ₹2,15,697 in Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar division and ₹1,89,991 in Amravati division. These are regional net domestic product measures, not the per-capita GSDP series used by the Finance Commission. They nevertheless show why a prosperous statewide average should not be mistaken for uniform prosperity, especially when districts compete for health, irrigation, transport and municipal investment.

There is a limit to the criticism. The Commission recommends allocation between states, not districts, and its formula did not reduce Maharashtra’s overall share. Responsibility for directing resources to Vidarbha and Marathwada rests substantially with Maharashtra itself. The per-capita trap is not proof of federal discrimination. It is a warning that equalisation between states cannot replace deliberate redistribution within them.

The grant gate: when access to money shapes policy

The Sixteenth Commission made a major change to the grants architecture. It recommended no revenue-deficit, sector-specific or state-specific grants, concentrating its national grant package of roughly ₹9.47 lakh crore on local governments and disaster management. For Maharashtra, which received no post-devolution revenue-deficit grants under the Fifteenth Commission, the significance of this shift lies in the new concentration of funding on local governments and disaster management. This reorientation brings the conditions governing access to grants and the purposes for which they may be used into sharper focus, directly influencing the state’s fiscal flexibility and policy choices.

For Maharashtra, the new recommendations provide ₹32,817 crore for rural local bodies and ₹46,803 crore for urban local bodies over five years. These are recommended allocations, not amounts already disbursed. Their promise is substantial, particularly where municipalities and Panchayats struggle to finance basic services.

The funds do not arrive without requirements. Local bodies must be duly constituted under the Constitution, the prescribed audited and provisional accounts must be available online and the state must comply with requirements concerning timely constitution of its State Finance Commission and laying of the action-taken report before the legislature within six months. Basic grants represent 80% of the principal local-body framework with half of that basic component tied to sanitation, waste or water management. The remaining basic portion and performance grants are classified as untied, though performance grants require separate benchmarks. Urban bodies, for example, face specified own-revenue growth tests from 2027–28.

These rules can promote credible accounts and functioning local institutions. They can also make essential financing harder to secure for bodies least equipped to satisfy administrative benchmarks. A condition on eligibility is different from a restriction on spending but both can influence policy.

The constitutional routes must also be kept distinct. The Commission’s local-body and disaster grants remain grants under Article 275(1). Article 282 separately permits public-purpose grants and provides a basis for Centrally Sponsored Schemes. The Sixteenth Commission did not transfer its Article 275 grants into Article 282. Nevertheless, these different channels collectively determine how far Maharashtra can finance priorities without adhering to externally specified purposes.

The practical stakes are not hypothetical. The CAG’s audit of Maharashtra’s accounts found that ₹1,304.50 crore in urban local-body grants released in 2023–24 related to an earlier withheld tranche, while grants recommended for that year had not been released. This was under the Fifteenth Commission and does not establish why funds were withheld or show any failure under the new recommendations. It does show why an announced allocation cannot be treated as money available for immediate policy choices.

The strongest objection: equalisation is not punishment

A substantial objection is that this critique mistakes the purpose of fiscal federalism. The Finance Commission is not required to return Union taxes to the regions that generate the greatest economic output. States with weaker revenue capacity need support to provide comparable public services. Maharashtra’s improved horizontal share also rebuts any suggestion that the revised formula simply punished its economic success.

Conditional grants deserve a defence too. Requiring elected local bodies, publicly available accounts and growth in own-source revenue can protect public funds and encourage sustainable municipal finance. The new structure also preserves significant untied spending, rather than placing every rupee under a project earmark. The Commission recommends that neither the Union nor the state add conditions beyond those it specifies, an important safeguard against multiplying administrative hurdles.

Yet these arguments do not settle the design question. A uniform compliance threshold can be easier for a wealthy municipal corporation than for an understaffed local body. Equally, removing every performance test might reward chronic non-disclosure and weaken incentives for financial reform. At the same time, the effectiveness of these transfers depends on Maharashtra’s own fiscal institutions and budgetary decisions. Its State Finance Commission and financial administration play an important role in addressing disparities in local fiscal capacity and ensuring that resources reach eligible local bodies. National accountability and state autonomy are not opposites but neither can substitute for the other.

A fairer federal bargain

The Sixteenth Finance Commission’s recommendations reveal a fundamental challenge in India’s fiscal federalism. Equitable redistribution between states remains essential but financial fairness cannot be measured solely through allocation percentages. Maharashtra’s improved share is significant, yet statewide indicators cannot fully reflect the developmental disparities of Vidarbha and Marathwada. Equally, substantial grant allocations offer limited practical value when access depends on conditions that financially weaker institutions may struggle to fulfil.

A more effective framework requires transparency alongside flexibility. The Union should clearly distinguish recommended allocations from actual releases, while Maharashtra must ensure timely onward transfers and strengthen its mechanisms for addressing regional inequalities. Compliance requirements should be accompanied by administrative and technical support, enabling local governments to meet accountability standards without allowing existing disadvantages to become barriers to funding.

Ultimately, neither unconditional financial autonomy nor rigid central oversight provides a complete answer. The constitutional balance lies in preserving legitimate redistribution, ensuring responsible expenditure and allowing states meaningful discretion over their developmental priorities. The success of fiscal federalism must therefore be judged not merely by how resources are divided but by whether those resources reach the institutions that need them and enable decisions responsive to the people they serve.

Frequently asked questions

What share of the divisible pool does Maharashtra get under the Sixteenth Finance Commission?
The Commission recommended keeping the states’ collective share at 41% of the divisible pool. Within it, Maharashtra’s share rose from 6.317% under the Fifteenth Commission to 6.441%. That is a share of the states’ pool, not of all Union revenue.

Is a Finance Commission grant the same as tax devolution?
No. Devolved tax revenue generally enters the state budget to be spent on its own priorities, while grants may prescribe purposes, eligibility tests or compliance requirements.

What conditions apply to the local-body grants for Maharashtra?
Local bodies must be duly constituted and their audited and provisional accounts must be online. The state must also constitute its State Finance Commission on time and lay the action-taken report before the legislature within six months.

Does the devolution formula reflect inequality inside Maharashtra?
Not directly, because the Commission allocates between states, not districts. The Economic Survey puts per-capita net domestic product at ₹3,17,801 for the state, against ₹2,15,697 in Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar division and ₹1,89,991 in Amravati division.

Further reading from AFPR: The UP Turnaround: Evaluating Uttar Pradesh’s Growth Trajectory · The Widespread Use of Freebies: Implications for Welfare, Governance, and Fiscal Sustainability in India

References

TABLE OF LEGISLATION

Constitution of India 1950

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Comptroller and Auditor General of India, ‘State Finances Audit Report for the Year 2023–24, Government of Maharashtra’ (Report No 3 of 2025) accessed 6 November 2026

Fifteenth Finance Commission, ‘Report for 2021–26, Volume I: Main Report’ (2020) accessed 6 November 2026

Government of Maharashtra, Directorate of Economics and Statistics, ‘Economic Survey of Maharashtra 2025–26’ (2026) accessed 6 November 2026

Ministry of Finance, Government of India, ‘Government Accepts 16th Finance Commission’s Recommendation to Retain Vertical Share of Devolution at 41 Percent’ (Press Information Bureau, 1 February 2026) accessed 6 November 2026

Sixteenth Finance Commission, ‘Report for 2026–31, Volume I: Main Report’ (2025) accessed 6 November 2026

Sixteenth Finance Commission, ‘Report for 2026–31, Volume II: Annexures’ (2025) accessed 6 November 2026

Further reading

Pay by UPI

UPI QR code for Adhyayan Foundation, payable with any UPI appSave QR to your phone
  1. Scan with Google Pay, PhonePe, Paytm, BHIM or your bank's UPI app. On a phone, save the code and use Scan from gallery, or pay to the UPI ID below.
  2. Pay to Adhyayan Foundation and add in the note.
  3. Confirm here with the UPI reference (UTR) shown in your app after payment.

UPI ID

Payments are received by Razorpay on behalf of the Adhyayan Foundation for Policy and Research. Questions: afpr.office@gmail.com